Action #2233

Add upper limit computation is csspec for NODES method

Added by Knödlseder Jürgen over 6 years ago. Updated almost 6 years ago.

Status:ClosedStart date:10/18/2017
Priority:NormalDue date:
Assigned To:Knödlseder Jürgen% Done:

100%

Category:-
Target version:1.6.0
Duration:

Description

So far upper limits are computed in csspec only for the SLICE method, but we should also compute upper limits for the NODES method. This requires the implementation of a likelihood profile method within csspec.


Recurrence

No recurrence.

History

#1 Updated by Knödlseder Jürgen almost 6 years ago

  • Assigned To set to Knödlseder Jürgen
  • Target version set to 1.6.0

#2 Updated by Knödlseder Jürgen almost 6 years ago

  • Status changed from New to In Progress
  • % Done changed from 0 to 50

I modified ctulimit so that the name of the parameter that should be varied to compute an upper limit can be specified using the parname parameter (if the parname parameter is blank, which is the default, the standard behavior is obtained).

I then added an upper limit computation to csspec, using the respective intensity nodes for upper limit computation.

As reference, here the results obtained with SLICE:

2018-06-15T15:23:26:  Bin 1 .....................: 1.221688e-10 +/- 5.373786e-12 [< 1.759066e-10] erg/cm2/s (TS = 1069.409)
2018-06-15T15:23:26:  Bin 2 .....................: 1.067982e-10 +/- 4.919193e-12 [< 1.559900e-10] erg/cm2/s (TS = 1064.433)
2018-06-15T15:23:26:  Bin 3 .....................: 1.011262e-10 +/- 4.647995e-12 [< 1.476061e-10] erg/cm2/s (TS = 1131.287)
2018-06-15T15:23:26:  Bin 4 .....................: 8.776835e-11 +/- 4.286944e-12 [< 1.306378e-10] erg/cm2/s (TS = 1046.271)
2018-06-15T15:23:26:  Bin 5 .....................: 7.005584e-11 +/- 3.853282e-12 [< 1.085886e-10] erg/cm2/s (TS = 853.251)
2018-06-15T15:23:26:  Bin 6 .....................: 5.759921e-11 +/- 3.576058e-12 [< 9.335975e-11] erg/cm2/s (TS = 684.670)
2018-06-15T15:23:26:  Bin 7 .....................: 4.871038e-11 +/- 3.294468e-12 [< 8.165503e-11] erg/cm2/s (TS = 598.169)
2018-06-15T15:23:26:  Bin 8 .....................: 4.619379e-11 +/- 3.306368e-12 [< 7.925744e-11] erg/cm2/s (TS = 530.022)
2018-06-15T15:23:26:  Bin 9 .....................: 3.258974e-11 +/- 2.893858e-12 [< 6.152829e-11] erg/cm2/s (TS = 355.286)
2018-06-15T15:23:26:  Bin 10 ....................: 3.437429e-11 +/- 3.165327e-12 [< 6.602754e-11] erg/cm2/s (TS = 334.213)
2018-06-15T15:23:26:  Bin 11 ....................: 1.745382e-11 +/- 2.478647e-12 [< 4.224027e-11] erg/cm2/s (TS = 129.701)
2018-06-15T15:23:26:  Bin 12 ....................: 1.818815e-11 +/- 2.835562e-12 [< 4.654376e-11] erg/cm2/s (TS = 106.882)
2018-06-15T15:23:26:  Bin 13 ....................: 2.153167e-11 +/- 3.448843e-12 [< 5.602009e-11] erg/cm2/s (TS = 125.532)
2018-06-15T15:23:26:  Bin 14 ....................: 1.819759e-11 +/- 3.681961e-12 [< 5.501719e-11] erg/cm2/s (TS = 72.438)
2018-06-15T15:23:26:  Bin 15 ....................: 1.406384e-11 +/- 3.759826e-12 [< 5.166209e-11] erg/cm2/s (TS = 45.063)
2018-06-15T15:23:26:  Bin 16 ....................: 8.405661e-12 +/- 3.432607e-12 [< 3.710673e-11] erg/cm2/s (TS = 19.313)
2018-06-15T15:23:26:  Bin 17 ....................: 1.760389e-11 +/- 5.869693e-12 [< 7.527111e-11] erg/cm2/s (TS = 28.969)
2018-06-15T15:23:26:  Bin 18 ....................: 1.095723e-11 +/- 5.480227e-12 [< 5.062560e-11] erg/cm2/s (TS = 12.875)
2018-06-15T15:23:26:  Bin 19 ....................: No event in this bin. Likelihood is zero. Bin is skipped.
2018-06-15T15:23:26:  Bin 20 ....................: No event in this bin. Likelihood is zero. Bin is skipped.

And here the results obtained with NODES:

2018-06-20T12:22:30:  Bin 1 .....................: 1.184822e-10 +/- 5.292844e-12 [< 1.288262e-10] erg/cm2/s (TS = 915.397)
2018-06-20T12:22:30:  Bin 2 .....................: 9.877345e-11 +/- 8.090496e-12 [< 1.129407e-10] erg/cm2/s (TS = 963.351)
2018-06-20T12:22:30:  Bin 3 .....................: 1.037521e-10 +/- 8.612275e-12 [< 1.172088e-10] erg/cm2/s (TS = 1022.947)
2018-06-20T12:22:30:  Bin 4 .....................: 8.732752e-11 +/- 7.440398e-12 [< 9.928920e-11] erg/cm2/s (TS = 980.725)
2018-06-20T12:22:30:  Bin 5 .....................: 6.932707e-11 +/- 6.552495e-12 [< 8.014925e-11] erg/cm2/s (TS = 817.823)
2018-06-20T12:22:30:  Bin 6 .....................: 5.690113e-11 +/- 5.928023e-12 [< 6.702479e-11] erg/cm2/s (TS = 663.018)
2018-06-20T12:22:30:  Bin 7 .....................: 4.669816e-11 +/- 5.349441e-12 [< 5.583374e-11] erg/cm2/s (TS = 584.479)
2018-06-20T12:22:30:  Bin 8 .....................: 5.043362e-11 +/- 5.843732e-12 [< 6.062021e-11] erg/cm2/s (TS = 514.298)
2018-06-20T12:22:30:  Bin 9 .....................: 2.784513e-11 +/- 4.196655e-12 [< 3.525792e-11] erg/cm2/s (TS = 340.687)
2018-06-20T12:22:30:  Bin 10 ....................: 4.238384e-11 +/- 6.416659e-12 [< 5.330281e-11] erg/cm2/s (TS = 327.308)
2018-06-20T12:22:30:  Bin 11 ....................: 1.395996e-11 +/- 5.507698e-12 [< 2.022604e-11] erg/cm2/s (TS = 126.441)
2018-06-20T12:22:30:  Bin 12 ....................: 1.819095e-11 +/- 2.828206e-11 [< 2.687340e-11] erg/cm2/s (TS = 104.569)
2018-06-20T12:22:30:  Bin 13 ....................: 2.305891e-11 +/- 1.549247e-10 [< 3.419148e-11] erg/cm2/s (TS = 123.773)
2018-06-20T12:22:30:  Bin 14 ....................: 1.817868e-11 +/- 5.955930e-10 [< 2.977335e-11] erg/cm2/s (TS = 71.488)
2018-06-20T12:22:30:  Bin 15 ....................: 1.433521e-11 +/- 2.683171e-09 [< 2.718826e-11] erg/cm2/s (TS = 42.700)
2018-06-20T12:22:30:  Bin 16 ....................: 8.489549e-12 +/- 9.516030e-09 [< 2.135030e-11] erg/cm2/s (TS = 16.728)
2018-06-20T12:22:30:  Bin 17 ....................: 9.033159e-12 +/- 5.730817e-08 [< 3.844165e-11] erg/cm2/s (TS = 26.340)
2018-06-20T12:22:30:  Bin 18 ....................: 3.411845e-11 +/- 7.637511e-07 [< 9.115606e-11] erg/cm2/s (TS = 19.364)
2018-06-20T12:22:30:  Bin 19 ....................: 6.484044e-32 +/- 2.390080e-25 [< 2.605015e-12] erg/cm2/s (TS = 0.010)
2018-06-20T12:22:30:  Bin 20 ....................: 5.493459e-32 +/- 5.493459e-07 [< 1.359484e-20] erg/cm2/s

#3 Updated by Knödlseder Jürgen almost 6 years ago

  • Status changed from In Progress to Closed
  • % Done changed from 50 to 100

Code merged into devel.

Also available in: Atom PDF